Book Review in Your Voice
1YV (Apr 2008) p6
||Doc. No. 2008.009
The Politics of Antisocial Behaviour: Amoral Panics
by Stuart Waiton [Short review.]
(Routledge, New York and London, 2008)
10: 0-415-95705-2/ISBN 13: 978-0-415-95705-2 (£60.)
Teachers are nowadays uncomfortably familiar with antisocial
behaviour. This book by a leading figure in US/UK sociology, drawing on much recent research
in that field, gives
a fascinating account. It describes a change which is perceived to have occurred during
the past two decades in the moral/cultural attitudes that shape the state’s legislative
and other governmental responses to what the author calls “panics”.
lay reader stumbles on sociological jargon, but that is easily mastered. For Waiton and
his colleagues a “panic” is what the OED describes as a sudden
and excessive feeling of alarm or fear, usually affecting a body of persons, originating
in some real or supposed danger vaguely apprehended, and leading to extravagant or injudicious
efforts to secure safety. This may arise in connection to the misbehaviour of children,
for example bullying, or threats to children, such as paedophilia. The sociologists cover
a wide field however. In the past two decades the British public has got into “panics” over
things affecting all age groups and ranging from AIDS to mad cow disease, from binge
drinking to raves.
These “panics” used to be based largely on moral
principles of right and wrong, and so are called by sociologists “moral panics”.
Waiton detects a remarkable recent shift to factors not morally linked, such as a hankering
for safety. Hence the
reference in his title to “amoral panics”.
Waiton gloomily concludes that the values of duty, chastity, sobriety and self discipline
that formed the basis standards of past moral campaigners are today felt to be alien – so
much so that those who embody them are seen as a threat to “the new amoral and
The above scarcely does justice to Waiton’s book.
A longer treatment 'Law-Churning and the Sociologist' (Doc. No.
2008.010) is also available on this site.